NPR Music

Sound And Silence: 'Remembering Sept. 11' At The Temple Of Dendur

Q2 | By Anastasia Tsioulcas

Published September 10, 2011 at 6:19 PM EDT

1 of 15 — The Temple of Dendur was the setting for Remembering September 11 concert by the Wordless Music Orchestra conducted by Ryan McAdams presented at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

The Temple of Dendur was the setting for Remembering September 11 concert by the Wordless Music Orchestra conducted by Ryan McAdams presented at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

/ Melanie Burford for NPR

2 of 15 — Remembering September 11, the Wordless Music Orchestra concedrt conducted by Ryan McAdams presented at The Temple of Dendur in The Sackler Wing at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

Remembering September 11, the Wordless Music Orchestra concedrt conducted by Ryan McAdams presented at The Temple of Dendur in The Sackler Wing at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

/ Melanie Burford for NPR

3 of 15 — Julian Donas Milstein, 6, relaxes before the Remembering September 11 concert, at The Temple of Dendur at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

Julian Donas Milstein, 6, relaxes before the Remembering September 11 concert, at The Temple of Dendur at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

/ Melanie Burford for NPR

4 of 15 — The quartet arrives for Remembering September 11, the Wordless Music Orchestra concert at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

The quartet arrives for Remembering September 11, the Wordless Music Orchestra concert at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

/ Melanie Burford for NPR

5 of 15 — The quartet plays "Tenebrae" by Osvaldo Golijov at the Remembering September 11 concert by the Wordless Music Orchestra conducted by Ryan McAdams presented at The Temple of Dendur at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

The quartet plays "Tenebrae" by Osvaldo Golijov at the Remembering September 11 concert by the Wordless Music Orchestra conducted by Ryan McAdams presented at The Temple of Dendur at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

/ Melanie Burford for NPR

6 of 15 — The audience, from across the reflecting pool, at the Remembering September 11 Wordless Music Orchestra concert at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

The audience, from across the reflecting pool, at the Remembering September 11 Wordless Music Orchestra concert at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

/ Melanie Burford for NPR

7 of 15 — Looking into the reflecting pool, at the Remembering September 11 Wordless Music Orchestra concert conducted by Ryan McAdams at The Temple of Dendur at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

Looking into the reflecting pool, at the Remembering September 11 Wordless Music Orchestra concert conducted by Ryan McAdams at The Temple of Dendur at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

/ Melanie Burford for NPR

8 of 15 — The Worldless Music Orchcestra, conducted by Ryan McAdams, plays "The Disintegration Loops, dlp 1.1" by William Basinski, orchestrated by Maxim Moston, at the Remembering September 11 concert at The Temple of Dendur at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

The Worldless Music Orchcestra, conducted by Ryan McAdams, plays "The Disintegration Loops, dlp 1.1" by William Basinski, orchestrated by Maxim Moston, at the Remembering September 11 concert at The Temple of Dendur at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

/ Melanie Burford for NPR

9 of 15 — Audience members took to the floor at the Remembering September 11 concert by the Wordless Music Orchestra conducted by Ryan McAdams, presented at The Temple of Dendur in The Sackler Wing at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

Audience members took to the floor at the Remembering September 11 concert by the Wordless Music Orchestra conducted by Ryan McAdams, presented at The Temple of Dendur in The Sackler Wing at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

/ Melanie Burford for NPR

10 of 15 — Letting the music wash over... at the Remembering September 11 Wordless Music Orchestra concert at The Temple of Dendur in The Sackler Wing at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

Letting the music wash over... at the Remembering September 11 Wordless Music Orchestra concert at The Temple of Dendur in The Sackler Wing at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

/ Melanie Burford for NPR

11 of 15 — Ryan McAdams conducts the Wordless Music Orchestra at the Remembering September 11 concert at The Temple of Dendur in The Sackler Wing at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

Ryan McAdams conducts the Wordless Music Orchestra at the Remembering September 11 concert at The Temple of Dendur in The Sackler Wing at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

/ Melanie Burford for NPR

12 of 15 — Members of the audience listen to Remembering September 11, a concert by the Wordless Music Orchestra conducted by Ryan McAdams presented at The Temple of Dendur in The Sackler Wing at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

Members of the audience listen to Remembering September 11, a concert by the Wordless Music Orchestra conducted by Ryan McAdams presented at The Temple of Dendur in The Sackler Wing at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

/ Melanie Burford for NPR

13 of 15 — Conductor Ryan McAdams hugs composer William Basinski after a performance of his "Disintegration Loops, dlp 1.1" at the Remembering September 11 Wordless Music Orchestra concert at The Temple of Dendur in The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

Conductor Ryan McAdams hugs composer William Basinski after a performance of his "Disintegration Loops, dlp 1.1" at the Remembering September 11 Wordless Music Orchestra concert at The Temple of Dendur in The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

/ Melanie Burford for NPR

14 of 15 — Remembering September 11, Wordless Music Orchestra conducted by Ryan McAdams presented at The Temple of Dendur in The Sackler Wing at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

Remembering September 11, Wordless Music Orchestra conducted by Ryan McAdams presented at The Temple of Dendur in The Sackler Wing at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

/ Melanie Burford for NPR

15 of 15 — Composer William Basinski (left) with Maxim Moston, who orchestrated Basinski's "Disintegration Loops, dlp 1.1." It recieved its world premiere at Remembering September 11, a concert by the Wordless Music Orchestra conducted by Ryan McAdams presented at The Temple of Dendur in The Sackler Wing at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

Composer William Basinski (left) with Maxim Moston, who orchestrated Basinski's "Disintegration Loops, dlp 1.1." It recieved its world premiere at Remembering September 11, a concert by the Wordless Music Orchestra conducted by Ryan McAdams presented at The Temple of Dendur in The Sackler Wing at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan, NY on September 11, 2011.

/ Melanie Burford for NPR

At the conclusion of the astonishing "Remembering September 11" concert, held by the Wordless Music Orchestra at the Metropolitan Museum of Art's Temple of Dendur on the 10th anniversary of Sept. 11, the audience responded with utter eloquence: two minutes of astonished silence, followed by wild applause.

The concert, presented as a live webcast by NPR Music and Q2, can now be heard as an archive stream — and it is an unmissable event.

Led by the dynamic conductor Ryan McAdams, New York's Wordless Music Orchestra performed four works centered on the idea of loss and remembrance. The program featured the world premiere of Maxim Moston's orchestration of an arresting work by William Basinski, The Disintegration Loops.

The concert also included three pieces for string quartet: Ingram Marshall's Fog Tropes II, Osvaldo Golijov's Tenebrae and Alfred Schnittke's Collected Songs Where Every Verse Is Filled With Grief, passionately and movingly performed by violinists Keats Dieffenbach and Caroline Shaw, violist Nadia Sirota and cellist Clarice Jensen.

The concert was held at the Metropolitan Museum of Art's Temple of Dendur, a Egyptian sandstone edifice from about 15 B.C. Now surrounded by a reflecting pool — evoking the waters of the Nile and housed within a glass atrium that overlooks Central Park — the temple is a space which lends itself beautifully to musical contemplation.

All the works on this program are haunting reflections on loss, grief and remembrance, interweaving past and present in hypnotic and moving arcs. For example, Golijov — with the violence of historical and contemporary Jerusalem in mind — loops melismatic quotations from Baroque composer François Couperin's somber Troisieme Leçon de Ténèbres.

Basinski's The Disintegration Loops had its genesis in the physical process of decay. In the midst of archiving and digitizing analog tapes from the early 1980s, the composer realized that his material was literally disintegrating, leaving eerily silent passages in the midst of lush, pastoral music — "my paradise lost," he says. He was finishing work on The Disintegration Loops as the destruction of Sept. 11 unfolded; he watched from his Brooklyn roof, just over the river from downtown Manhattan.

The "Remembering September 11" concert webcast was hosted by NPR Music's Anastasia Tsioulcas and WQXR/Q2's Helga Davis. You can hear the entire webcast at the link above.